12 Best Down Alternative Comforter Reviews – Our Top Picks
If you are a cold sleeper, then strongly consider getting yourself a comforter for amazingly cozy nights. Particularly, we suggest down alternative comforters because of their hypoallergenic properties and eco-friendliness.
To help you choose, we will showcase our personal Top 12 of the best down alternative comforters you can find out there. We shall also provide you with a number of handy tips to give you a better understanding of down alternative hypoallergenic comforters and how to find the best one.
12 Best Down Alternative Comforters
Below are our top 12 picks – down alternative comforters that we consider the best you can find. For each comforter, we’ve deeply researched what we are dealing with, and we’ve also paid attention to buyer feedback.
In our opinion, the best way to determine the quality of a product – including a down alternative comforter – is to read the reviews of past buyers. So though we’ll provide you with some useful insights into our picks, you should do some digging of your own as well!
Once we are done with our top, we’ll cover a few important points to help you better understand down alternative comforters. And to top it off, we’ll then move on to our comprehensive down alternative comforter buyer’s guide!
1. Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert
QUICK SUMMARY
If you are shopping on a tight budget, consider this comforter duvet from Utopia. The stitching and overall quality here aren’t the best, but they are pretty nice for the money.
The Utopia comforter features a siliconized fiberfill – this filling is soft, fluffy, and breathable. The comforter is also box-stitched, which allows the filling to stay where it’s supposed to be.
The filling here is weighted at 350 GSM, which makes this comforter a good all-season pick. If you are a hot sleeper or live in a warm area, the Utopia comforter should be a good buy.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
2. Sleep Restoration All-Season Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
The Sleep Restoration comforter is priced a little higher than the Utopia comforter but offers solid quality. With its reinforced stitching, it’s not as delicate as the Utopia comforter, so it will withstand washes and general use much better.
What we also like about this comforter is its two-sided design that allows you to easily change the feel and look of your bedroom. A few dual-tone color options are available too.
The filling here is 350GSM down alternative fiber fill. This is all-season filling that should work for most needs, and judging by buyer feedback, it’s very soft and fluffy. The box stitching also keeps the filling in place to ensure a consistent level of comfort.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
3. Egyptian Bedding Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
If you want something high-quality and luxurious, then strongly consider this comforter from Egyptian Bedding.
The highlight of this piece of bedding is the 100% Egyptian cotton cover. If you didn’t know, Egyptian cotton is widely considered as the softest and most durable variety of cotton. Not only that, but the particular cotton used in this comforter boasts a thread count of 600/square inch and is very smooth.
The fiber filling in this comforter is nice too – it’s perhaps not as thick and soft as in true down comforters, but it’s better than anything we’ve seen so far. For some perspective, the fill power here is about 750, which is on the higher end of what you can find in comforters.
Advertised at medium warmth, this comforter is also on the warmer side – mainly thanks to the dense filling. The comforter is box-stitched too to keep the filling in place.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
4. Amrapur Overseas Medium Down Alternative Duvet Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
The Amrapur down alternative duvet/comforter is one of the lightest and coolest picks on our list.
The fill weight here seems to be around 200 GSM (vs the 350GSM weight in the Utopia comforter). The fluff here won’t be as up there, but if you usually don’t get too cold at night, then perhaps such a light fill will work better for you.
What’s also nice about this comforter is that Amrapur offers it in 17 colors (as of this review), so it’s easy to adapt to your current bedroom style.
In terms of price and quality, this box-stitched comforter is similar to the Utopia comforter, but it’s lighter and doesn’t have cover-fitting loops (which might be a big downside for some people).
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
5. Elegant Comfort All-Season Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
The Elegant Comfort down alternative comforter is yet another affordable pick on this top!
This model seems to be built a little bit better than our previous pocket-friendly comforters. Judging by user feedback, the comforter holds up after washes pretty well, and it overall feels fluffy and comfy.
This comforter is also a summer comforter – although no fill weight numbers are provided, it’s light and should work for warm sleepers. One buyer even comfortably used it in the warm winters of southern Florida!
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
6. Royal Hotel Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
This down alternative comforter from Royal Hotel boasts excellent quality. On par with the Egyptian Bedding comforter, the Royal Hotel comforter is a great option if you have the budget.
This comforter is a little cheaper than the Egyptian Bedding comforter though and doesn’t have an Egyptian cotton cover. Instead, it features a soft and smooth microfiber cover that should be fine for most people’s needs.
The box-stitched filling in the Royal Hotel comforter is made of polyester fiber and is on the lighter side too. Providing medium warmth, this comforter isn’t as thick and fluffy as some people may want, but it’s a great option for warm sleepers or not so cold areas.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
7. Royal Hotel Overfilled Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
This Royal Hotel comforter is a little different from the previous one.
Most notably, it has much more fluff and filling. If we compare the two Royal Hotel comforters size-to-size, you get about 1.5-1.6 times more filling here. The fill power in this comforter is 750 as well, which is among the highest on this top. This comforter isn’t the thickest out there, but it’s quite up there.
The second important difference is the cover – here, it’s made from cotton. If you like cotton bedding, then this comforter should be ideal for you. With 300 threads/square inch, the cover is a little coarse, but it will be fine for most people, and it still boasts the softness and breathability of cotton that many people love.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
8. Chezmoi Collection Light Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
This down alternative comforter from Chezmoi Collection is a nice option if you want something light. The Chezmoi comforter is available in 3 variants – light (180 GSM), medium (250 GSM), and ultra (320 GSM).
The ultra size is pretty warm, but definitely not the warmest on our list. All in all, this is one of the lightest down alternative comforters on the top. This is great for people who don’t need much additional warmth, as well as for buyers in warmer regions.
What we also like about this comforter very much is that it’s available in a wide range of sizes for all kinds of needs. Most other comforters on this top only offer 3 sizes, unfortunately.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
9. KASENTEX All-Season Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
The KASENTEX all-season down alternative comforter is a nice buy if you want a high-quality lightweight comforter. At 250 GSM, this comforter offers balanced warmth that should work for most people.
Being one of the pricier comforters on this list, the KASENTEX comforter also offers a quality box-stitched construction with tough seams. The filling is remarkable as well – hydrophilic and moisture-absorbent, it keeps you comfortable in sleep and withstands washes more easily.
The double-side reversible design is nice as well in that it allows you to quickly alter the look of your bedroom.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
10. GrayEagle Bedding Co. All-Season Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
This one is an ideal option if you have a large bed or want your comforter to hang down the sides of your bed. Available in two sizes – Supreme King (118 x 114 inches) and Super King (120 x 98 inches) – the GrayEagle comforter is the largest on our list.
Both sizes are generously filled as well – Supreme King has 130 ounces of fill, while Super King has 116 ounces. So even though this comforter is marketed as all-season, it’s very warm and will probably work the best from late fall to early spring.
The overall quality of this comforter is great too. This is no surprise because the GrayEagle comforter is quite steeply priced. But note that the cover with its thread count of 250 may be a little coarse.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
11. Sleep Philosophy Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
Thanks to its moisture-wicking properties, the Sleep Philosophy comforter offers remarkable sleeping comfort – perhaps the best on the list.
The cotton sateen cover is notable as well. Although this cotton variety isn’t as luxurious as Egyptian cotton, it offers softness, smoothness, and durability far superior to regular cotton.
The most unique feature in this comforter, however, is the Thinsulate insulation from 3M. This insulation offers excellent warmth while keeping the comforter lightweight.
Speaking of warmth, Sleep Philosophy offers this comforter in 3 warmth options – Year-Round Warmth, Warmer for fall and spring, and Maximum Warmth for winters. So no matter what your needs are, this comforter is likely to meet them.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
12. HIG Down Alternative Comforter
QUICK SUMMARY
Finally, we have the HIG down alternative comforter. This is yet another inexpensive comforter, so it’s a good option if you didn’t like any of our previous budget picks.
The HIG down alternative comforter doesn’t really have anything new or amazing to offer. However, it has all the basics you should be looking for in a down alternative comforter, including corner loops for easy covering, box-stitched construction, pretty decent (but not great) build quality, and a few size options.
What catches the eye is that HIG includes a pair of pillow shams. This is nice if you happen to be looking for pillow shams, but otherwise, we wouldn’t say that it’s a huge buying point for this comforter.
WHAT WE LIKED
WHAT WE DIDN'T LIKE
What Is Down Alternative?
Down alternative is an alternative to natural down feather fillings. Down, if you didn’t know, is the fine feathers found under the tough exterior feathers of birds. These feathers are a popular filling for pillows, comforters, and other beddings.
The purpose of down alternative in comforters is to simulate the feel and warmth delivered by natural down. Manufacturers of comforters and other bed products use a wide range of both synthetic and natural materials to deliver a feel that’s close to what you’re getting with down.
All in all, down alternative fillings are made for two categories of buyers:
Those who have allergies to natural down.
Those who think down feather fillings are unethical.
Down alternative comforters and other bed products are also usually cheaper than their natural down counterparts, so they are also a good choice for buyers on a budget. Additionally, down alternative is actually much easier to wash and take care of than down – mainly because down alternative is often machine-washable.
With that said, down alternative has a number of downsides that you should know about:
Down alternative isn’t as breathable as down. You are more likely to get hot and sweaty with a down alternative comforter.
Down alternative comforters offer less fluff and comfort.
The down alternative filling is heavier than down. This is an especially big problem with comforters that have a lot of filling.
After machine-washing, down alternatives tend to shrink, so they aren’t as durable as natural down comforters.
Generally, down alternative comforters have a shorter lifespan than down comforters.
If you are looking for fluff and comfort, then a down comforter would be an ideal choice for you. On the other hand, you should get a down alternative comforter if any of these points applies to you:
Your budget is tight.
You consider down fillings unethical.
You are allergic to natural down.
If you don’t care about any of these points, then a down comforter would be a better buy for the money. It would last longer and be more comfortable.
What’s The Differences Between A Comforter And Duvet?
Before moving to our buyer’s guide, we feel that we should also make a distinction between duvets and comforters.
The two beddings are similar and similar purposes. However, they aren’t exactly the same, which often confuses buyers.
Let’s quickly define what duvets and comforters are:
A duvet consists of a bag filled with a filler made of down, feathers, wool, or synthetic materials. Duvets are designed to be tucked into a duvet cover – however, duvets and duvet covers are usually sold separately. Duvets are often called comforters, which confuses people even more.
Comforters are built like duvets, but they do not require any additional covers. You could insert your comforter into a cover, but this isn’t a must.
So essentially, a duvet is a type of bedding that is designed to be covered, while a comforter doesn’t need any covers.
If you are still confused, then here are a few more distinctions:
Duvets are often used instead of a top bed sheet, allowing for quicker and more convenient bed-making.
Duvets are usually cheaper than comforters, but if you add the cost of a duvet cover, the difference may not be that big.
Because duvets are to be covered, they allow you to play around with the style of your bed and bedroom.
Duvets are usually sized like the beds they are intended for. In contrast, comforters are larger, often hanging down the bed’s sides.
Comforters are usually placed over the top sheet. But you may use a comforter just like a duvet.
Comforters are typically not as thick as duvets.
Because comforters don’t require covers, they aren’t as easy to keep clean as duvets. With a duvet, you can toss the cover into a washing machine, and your cleaning job is mostly done.
The points above should give you an idea of which bedding would work the best for you. But generally, comforters are great for homeowners who don’t want to deal with any covers, while duvets would be ideal if you want to be able to alter the appearance of your bedroom.
Note that in practice, “duvet” and “comforter” are very often used interchangeably. You can get a duvet and use it like a comforter, and vice versa. But we still think that telling the two types of bedding apart is important.
What To Look For When Shopping For The Best Down Alternative Comforter
Now, we can proceed to our buyer’s guide. Since you already have an understanding what a comforter is, catching our points will be easier for you.
Final Words
Picking the right comforter isn’t as easy as picking a kitchen appliance or furniture – there are many subjective factors that should be kept in mind. And worst of all, when shopping online, understanding what you are dealing with can be challenging.
With our top picks and buyer’s guide, you should be pretty safe. But still, you should make an effort to gather as much information as you can on down alternative comforters in general and the comforter that specifically interests you. The more information you have, the less you will have to struggle when looking for the best down alternative comforter.
